Settings

Theme

QIP = PSPACE

cacm.acm.org

90 points by kvs 15 years ago · 10 comments

Reader

poet 15 years ago

A link to the actual paper for those interested: http://www.cs.cmu.edu/~odonnell/hits09/jain-ji-upadhay-watro....

DanielRibeiro 15 years ago

People wondering how IP = PSPACE can delve further into the free draft of this great book on the subject: http://www.cs.princeton.edu/theory/index.php/Compbook/Draft

hypersoar 15 years ago

This news (although not this particular link) was posted over a year ago.

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=729335

tocomment 15 years ago

Does this mean quantum computers can't do anything classical computers can't? Does it let the air out of quantum computing? Or am I misreading?

  • Dabacon 15 years ago

    No. It means that for the complexity class of interactive proofs quantum and classical are the same (when you ignore the number of rounds involved.) This doesn't tell us anything about whether quantum polynomial time equals classical polynomial time. The "IP" classes have problems that are very intractable...this basically says that for these very intractable problems quantum won't help (with the caveat that the quantum seems to allow fewer rounds in the interactive proof.)

    • palish 15 years ago

      the quantum seems to allow fewer rounds in the interactive proof

      This seems important. What if IP -> QIP is like O(N) -> O(log N)?

      • Dabacon 15 years ago

        The result, IIRC, is that all of QIP can be done in three rounds, whereas if the same held in the classical world the polynomial hierarchy would collapse (which is considered about as likely as P=NP). Not of practical value, but it does point out that QIP is a slightly different beast than IP when you include the number of rounds.

  • DanielRibeiro 15 years ago

    No. It means that, when solving harder problems (way beyond NP, as PSPACE is a really big class), it doesn't matter having a quantum computer.

  • michaelty 15 years ago

    Crap, we're still going to be using C when we get our flying cars!

Groxx 15 years ago

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IP_(complexity)

Buh? Anyone care to explain what sort of problems would fall into this description?

Keyboard Shortcuts

j
Next item
k
Previous item
o / Enter
Open selected item
?
Show this help
Esc
Close modal / clear selection