Settings

Theme

Warner Brothers reports own site as illegal

bbc.co.uk

76 points by ilghiro · 18 comments

Reader

5 threads
jameskilton

I don't see the problem here. If they so desperately want the content removed, then Google should happily kill all of those links right away!

  • joekrie

    Complying and taking down the legitimate links should force WB to properly review their requests.

    This case is kind of funny, but something similar started happening when banks started automating foreclosures. People who were up to date on their mortgages were getting evicted from exactly the same kind of negligence WB is exhibiting here.

    • travmatt

      In his book 'Bailout', the Special Inspector General of TARP, Neil Barofsky, lists a multitude of reasons as to why so many Americans were wrongly foreclosed on by mortgage servicers.

      At the top of the list was fraud and lies by the mortgage servicers, many of whom lied to homeowners and convinced them to skip payments on their homes in the hopes of qualifying for a modification, so that they could rack up late fees and then foreclose.

    • sonthonax

      How does one get evicted due to a computer error? Wouldn't a rather simple court case be able to determine that X amount was being paid to be bank every month?

  • andrewclunn

    Agreed, take the site down. If they feed the request was made in error,then there's a process for that.

    • ourmandave

      If I was a snarky lawyer, I would offer to represent them against themselves, pro bono.

      • __john

        You jest, but google "can a company sue itself". You'll see a list of articles about banks suing themselves over foreclosures.

      • actsasbuffoon

        As a snarky non-lawyer, I'd offer to defend them from themselves for a literal mountain of cash.

coldcode

If I were Google I would ban the whole domain, clearly a lot of piracy here! That way they might be more careful in the future.

quickben

Just goes to show that no thought enters their flagging.

chris_wot

I hope that Google complied with the law and demanded to have legal proof that they weren't violating the DMCA before they reindexed the material.

Then it would be nice to sue them to kingdom come.

jnmandal

They should probably add a whitelist to their bot

  • sleepychu

    >The request was submitted on behalf of Warner Brothers by Vobile, a company that files hundreds of thousands of takedown requests every month.

Keyboard Shortcuts

j
Next item
k
Previous item
o / Enter
Open selected item
?
Show this help
Esc
Close modal / clear selection