Settings

Theme

Windows 10 upgrades will cost $119 after July 29, Win 10 on 300M devices

engadget.com

26 points by jfuhrman 9 years ago · 28 comments

Reader

EvanAnderson 9 years ago

You can lock-in your upgrade eligibility w/o actually installing Windows 10.

The WinToUSB tool (http://www.easyuefi.com/wintousb/) can create a bootable Windows 10 USB thumb-drive (or hard disk drive, which is much faster). You boot from this drive to lock-in your entitlement w/o actually having to upgrade to Windows 10. (You must use the Windows 10 "1511" update to do this. The earlier Windows 10 version won't activate w/ a Windows 7/8/8.1 product key.)

Create and boot from a Windows 10 thumb-drive and use the "Activate Windows" functionality with your existing Windows 7/8.1 key. This will lock-in that PC's Windows 10 entitlement w/ Microsoft's servers. No changes are made to your existing hard disk drive.

If you're paranoid like me, you can even disconnect your hard disk drive while you perform this procedure to ensure no changes are made.

I validated the "digital entitlement" to install Windows 10 after performing this procedure on a PC. I put a clean hard disk drive in it, installed Windows 10 from scratch, skipped entering the product key during install, and found that the machine was "Activated with a digital entitlement" after installation completed.

  • Gmo 9 years ago

    Thanks, I want to upgrade to Win 10 eventually, but don't really have time to do it before the deadline, your post could really help me !

hacker_9 9 years ago

I'm still so undecided whether to upgrade from Windows 7 to 10. On the one hand a free upgrade to the latest OS is so very tempting, but then I read about how there is no privacy, people calling the installation malware, and the ugly flat UI look. Not to mention does it push that basic tiles screen from Windows 8 in your face? The one that is meant for a tablet/phone, and has no place on a desktop?

I wonder if I'm going to miss out on new games that are DirectX 12 only, which is Windows 10 only. I see on Steam [1] that 43% of people use Windows 10 now. Could this be a problem soon?

So many pros and cons to upgrading, I can't believe I even have to think about this stuff. Very unhappy with Microsoft about it all in all, who usually I don't have a problem with.

[1] http://store.steampowered.com/hwsurvey

  • bargl 9 years ago

    I'm going to give you my opinion on this topic but I'm going to preface it with I'm biased. I'm also basing it on the fact that you're already using Windows 7.

    Windows 10 is a better experience in my opinion. The search works much better on the machine, they fixed some of the basic tools to manage MS and they have added scaling (which doesn't work well on old winforms apps but it is awesome otherwise).

    You're already on windows so the privacy is a big deal anyway, they could just push an update that sends data back to them and make that the default. I mean what's stopping them right? (There may be a legal reason I don't know about.)

    Windows 10 allows you to click a bunch of toggles that Microsoft says they are going to respect. If you were on Linux I'd say, ok you don't trust them don't use it, but you are already trusting Microsoft in this regard, so look into what you have to turn off and turn it off.

    Cortana is awesome. I actually like using it a lot of times, but that's me and this is 1000% an opinion. I love the voice recognition tools out there.

    If you want to stay on windows 7 due to security I'd say take the plunge and go linux. If you aren't upgrading because of the UI, I'd say try it out I really enjoy it. If you want to roll back you can.

    If you are going to game in the future or buy a pc in the future you will HAVE to get windows 10. So holding out against windows 10 now but not windows in general just doesn't make sense to me. Eventually windows 7 will stop getting security updates, and you''ll have a really hard time getting anything to run on it. You'll be forced out anyway, and then you'll be paying for it.

    Wow that was a REALLY long response, but basically my opinion is upgrade or switch to Linux. Also a lot of game support is moving to Linux so that isn't a terrible option either. I just don't think Win 7 is a long term decision either way.

  • raesene9 9 years ago

    I think you may have a few mis-conceptions about windows 10...

    1) no privacy... not really. Windows (like several other OS' and applications) will, by default, send data to the cloud for processing and collect telemetry data about the user. I really wish they had made it easier to opt out of (and indeed not made the privacy invasive stuff the default) but I wouldn't say that equates to "no privacy". Also with a bit of effort you can turn that stuff off.

    2) People calling it malware... well that's a subjective description, not sure I see the basis for it.

    3) Ugly flat UI.. Again that's a matter of taste I guess. Personally I quite like Windows 10's new look

    4) Nope the windows 8 full start screen is gone in 10 in desktop mode.

    • TrevorJ 9 years ago

      >no privacy... not really.

      > really wish they had made it easier to opt out of (and indeed not made the privacy invasive stuff the default)

      Which is it?

      • raesene9 9 years ago

        well some not great privacy settings is not the same as "no privacy" therefore I would suggest those statements are not contradictory.

  • blackoil 9 years ago

    Unless you decide to move to Linux/OSX, would recommend you to migrate to Windows 10.

    You can stop lots of upload by disabling Cortana and other cloud features, but you can't be 100% sure of what data is leaving your system. On other hand with popularity of cloud services and mobile sending all data back home, overall privacy feels like a lost cause.

    Win 10 gives substantial performance improvements, new features and also developer experience is so much improved. Most the kinks of UI are sorted out, and it feels much more polished and at home on a laptop.

  • kyriakos 9 years ago

    You are already missing out from games released on the windows store. Most from microsoft studios. Gears of War 4 coming out for Windows 10 only

    • seanp2k2 9 years ago

      The Windows store is the worst App Store experience I've ever had. I bought an Xbox Elite controller ($150) and wireless dongle ($25) to use it with Win10, since it doesn't use Bluetooth, with is a big part of why I got it (DS4 controller was having major issues for me in an apartment, I'm guessing because 2.4ghz is so crazy overcrowded here -- I can't get a solid 802.11AC or N signal across a 1-bedroom apartment here).

      The controller has a settings app, which is ONLY available through the windows store. This download failed many many times with error codes (why MS uses those when it's not DOS days anymore boggles my mind) which led nowhere useful online. After seriously hours of tinkering with registry settings, powershell to remove and reinstall the Windows store program (not a normal program you can add or remove, but more like a windows "component", like Cortana, which you can't completely remove without breaking the start menu...get ClassicShell and it might work). I finally got it working with a combination of the CCleaner registry repair tool + tweaking.com Windows Repair, using "completely reset Windows store" IIRC.

      Why is it that with Linux, you can do the equivalent of swapping the engine while you're driving down the freeway without a hiccup, while in Windows, changing a flat tire requires removing the transmission and trying random screws you find on the side of the road to put it back together?

      Terrible experience in all, and in my hours of researching trying to get this stupid thing working, I found that I was very much not alone in my Windows store problems. I would personally never spend money on the Windows store, since it's proven itself to be a huge piece of junk.

      • kyriakos 9 years ago

        I'm not saying the windows store is good but it does offer some exclusive games and if that's the OPs thing then he has no choice

foolofatom 9 years ago

Reasons I would rather be on Windows 7:

- search stopped working after upgrading - twice it has changed my local account to a Microsoft account without my approval (and failed to sync a password change from online) - after upgrading my computer my copy now requires activation and support says I have to buy a copy since my product key was a 7 one before upgrading

  • bargl 9 years ago

    I have the opposite problem. WIndows 10 at home and windows 7 at the office. I hate using the Win 7 at work.

    I love the new search on win 10. I feel that the windows key is smarter now.

    If it did that to me with the product key I'd be pissed. If customer support doesn't fix that I'd consider that a reason to move to linux too. It hasn't happened to me but if it had I'd move.

joesmo 9 years ago

So will they stop force upgrading systems now or will we come home to find a ransom note for $119 now and an unusable system? That part, by far the most important, is not even addressed.

  • noxToken 9 years ago

    As in pay for Win10 or stare at this upgrade modal?

    I can't tell if your serious or sarcastic.

    • joesmo 9 years ago

      Yes, exactly. I'm totally serious. Considering Microsoft's actions up to this point vis a vis Windows 10, it's hardly a stretch of the imagination that they'd do that. It's amazing how many issues in technology come down to trust--or lack of it--when you boil things down.

DanielDent 9 years ago

A while back Microsoft said that Windows 10 will continue to be free for customers who will benefit from it's assistive technologies. I don't know how they plan to implement this. Many assistive technologies are sometimes helpful to individuals that would not typically be described as 'disabled'.

It seems like such a wide open backdoor to continued free upgrades that it almost looks intentional...

krapp 9 years ago

    To the last, I grapple with thee; 
    From Hell's heart, I stab at thee; 
    For hate's sake, I spit my last breath at thee.
I will either continue using Windows 8, or replace my current system with Linux entirely. If I didn't need to use VS and some Adobe software, I would already have gotten rid of Windows.

But, even though I would probably like a lot of what Windows 10 has to offer, I will never, ever voluntarily upgrade to 10. I'll buy a new laptop with 10 installed, but not upgrade, just because I object to Microsoft's aggressive tactics so much, that I want to make a futile gesture of holding on to my current Windows OS out of sheer irrational spite.

  • seanp2k2 9 years ago

    And because upgraded versions of Windows suffer from extreme bloat, instability, and weird random issues that you can typically not fix without a clean reinstall anyway.

atomi 9 years ago

If Microsoft did this from the start, Win 10 install numbers would be disappointing.

  • WorldMaker 9 years ago

    Which has been the status quo for Windows. Microsoft admitted very early on that in general consumers only "upgrade" Windows when they pick up a new machine with the new Windows version installed.

  • znpy 9 years ago

    this is why they are doing it now.

username3 9 years ago

Is there any way to get the Windows 10 upgrade key without upgrading?

y7 9 years ago

I find it a bit ironic that after their very aggressive forced update practices [1][2], they're now gonna charge people for it.

[1] http://www.cnet.com/news/microsoft-pays-woman-10000-over-for...

[2] https://www.reddit.com/r/technology/comments/4mcdon/i_live_i...

  • algorithmsRcool 9 years ago

    They were always going to charge for it. The first time it was announced they stated it was going to be free to upgrade for the first year.

  • summarite 9 years ago

    That's how you get the goodies holdouts. Do it now or pay 120$¥€...

walterbell 9 years ago

When will the last Skylake OEM machines be sold with Windows 7 downgrade rights?

Keyboard Shortcuts

j
Next item
k
Previous item
o / Enter
Open selected item
?
Show this help
Esc
Close modal / clear selection